The Old Salt Trophy is to be awarded semi-annually to the skipper 65 years of age or older regardless of class with the best showing. Modified in 1989 or 1990 with the permission of as many donors as could be reached to reduce the minimum age to 60.
| Year | SPRING | FALL |
| 72 | WALTER ROWE(I.C.) | GEORGE HARRAH(BJ) |
| 73 | WALTER ROWE(I.C.) | GEORGE HARRAH(BJ) |
| 75 | WALTER ROWE(I.C.) | -- |
| 76 | WALTER ROWE(I.C.) | -- |
| 78 | WALTER ROWE(I.C.) | -- |
| 79 | -- | NORM HOSFORD(L) |
| 89 | BERNARD DOROGUSKER(BJ) | -- |
| 90 | VARICK HARRISON(BJ) | BERNARD DOROGUSKER(BJ) |
| 91 | VARICK HARRISON(BJ) | WALT STUBNER(BJ) |
| 92 | WALT STUBNER(BJ) | WALT STUBNER(BJ) |
| 93 | WALT STUBNER(BJ) | WALT STUBNER(BJ) |
| 94 | WALT STUBNER(BJ) | WALT STUBNER(BJ) |
| 95 | WALT STUBNER(BJ) | DENNIS POSEY(JY) |
| 96 | ED BIRCH(BJ) | ED BIRCH(BJ) |
| 97 | ED BIRCH(BJ) | ED BIRCH(BJ) |
| 98 | ED BIRCH(BJ) | ED BIRCH(BJ) |
| 99 | DENNIS POSEY(JY) | ED BIRCH(BJ) |
| 2000 | BILL GROVER(BJ)(E) | DENNIS POSEY(JY) |
| 2001 | Bill Chatman (BJ) | Ron Noe (Etchells) |
| 2002 | Ed Birch (BJ) | BILL BELL(BJ) |
| 2003 | Bill Grover (Etchells) | RICK HARRISON |
| 2004 | Ed Birch (BJ) | Dennis Posey (Ideal 18) |
| 2005 | Dennis Posey (Ideal 18) | Dennis Posey (Ideal 18) |
| 2006 | Leighton Lee | |
| 2007 | Dennis Posey (Ideal 18) | |
| 2008 | ||
| 2009 | Peter Harding | |